Date of Incident: 08  September 2007
Time of Incident: 2100hrs

On Saturday Sept 8, 2007 at approx 9:00 PM a heavy set white male approx 5’5’’ in height, robbed the Rutter’s Farm Store at 1425 Seven Valleys Rd, Seven Valleys, in North Codorus Twp. The subject entered the store and displayed a note claiming he had a gun. The note demanded cash from the store clerk. The male fled on foot with an undisclosed amount of money. He ran to a waiting car parked in a near by parking lot. The vehicle was described as a late model red Pontiac Grand Am.   

Updated Information:        Two persons were arrested on 09-10-07 at 8:00 PM in the Armed Robbery case as listed above.  Arrested were:

1) W/M, Alan David Hickman, 700 blk. Wilson Ave., Hanover, PA DOB 12-28-67

2) W/F, Holly A. Feudale, 700 blk. Wilson Ave., Hanover, PA DOB 12-26-67 

After the information regarding the armed robbery was released to the public, we received a call from a person who advised that they were acquaintances of a couple and that she believed had committed the robbery.  She provided names and other pertinent information.  We also had store surveillance footage and still photos that were provided by the business.  Sgt. Lisa Layden met with the caller that provided the original information on 09-10-07 and provided a positive identification of the suspect.  A second person also made positive identification of the suspect.   

Sgt. Layden contacted the Hanover Police Department at 8:00 PM on 09-10-07 when information was obtained that advised that the suspect and his girlfriend, Feudale, were at their residence in Hanover.  Officers from both departments located both suspects at the residence and were taken into custody without incident.

 Feudale is also charged similarly as is Hickman.  Information suggests that she drove the waiting vehicle that Hickman left the scene in.  The suspect’s vehicle was also located and taken from the scene as evidence in the crime. 

Charges for both are as follows: Robbery (F1), Theft (F1), and Criminal Conspiracy (M1).  Both were transported to York County Central Booking on 09-10-07.